Bargaining Obligations Regarding Unilateral Changes

By Noah R. Jordan, Esq.


On Friday December 15, 2017, the National Labor Relations Board issued another 3-2 decision, in Raytheon Network Centric Systems, 365 NLRB No. 161.  In that case, the Board held that an employer’s actions do not constitute a unilateral change in working conditions when those actions are similar in kind and degree to an established past practice between that employer and a union regarding similar unilateral actions, regardless of whether the collective bargaining agreement in place when that practice was started had expired when the employer’s action was taken.  This holding clears the way for employers to make unilateral changes without such action being treated as a change in working conditions requiring bargaining prior to implementation. 

In so holding, the Board overruled yet another previous decision, this one from 2016 in E.I. du Pont de Nemours, 364 NLRB No. 113.  In that case the Board had held that employers must bargain over any changes to working conditions consistent with a past practice if that practice had been created pursuant to a management rights clause in an expired collective bargaining agreement or if the change involved employer discretion.

Why this decision is important for you: Once more, this decision expands the rights of employers and rolls back those of unions and employees.  Under this holding, employers will have greater flexibility in making unilateral changes to employees’ working conditions without first having to bargain with unions.  Employers now will be able to make changes based on practices in place under previous collective bargaining agreements even if new agreements have since been agreed to.

Read about other recent overturns:

Hy-Brand Industrial Contractors, 365 NLRB 156

Boeing Company, 365 NLRB No. 154

Follow Us: Follow Rothman Gordon on LinkedIn Follow Rothman Gordon on YouTubeFollow Rothman Gordon on Twitter

Sign up for our newsletters

Primerus Member
ACG Pittsburgh Sponsor
IUP Family Business sponsor
Master Builders Association of Western PA logo and link
Rothman Gordon was a Top Workplace 2011Rothman Gordon was a Top Workplace 2012 Rothman Gordon was a Top Workplace 2013
Rothman Gordon was a Top Workplace 2014 Rothman Gordon was a Top Workplace 2015 Rothman Gordon was a Top Workplaces 2016
Rothman Gordon is a Pittsburgh Marathon sponsor